Nick's Gyro & Phillys: Casual Mediterranean Sandwiches in Columbia

What you'll find at Nick's Gyro & Phillys

Nick's Gyro & Phillys is a casual sandwich shop in Columbia that specializes in gyros, Philly cheesesteaks, and other handheld Mediterranean and American fare. The menu centers on grilled meat sandwiches—lamb and beef gyros, chicken gyros, and Philly-style sandwiches with steak, chicken, or Italian meats. Most orders come with your choice of toppings: lettuce, tomato, onion, tzatziki sauce, and hot peppers. The space is small and counter-service, designed for quick lunch or dinner stops rather than lingering meals.

The gyros are the signature draw. They're made with meat cooked on a vertical rotisserie, then shaved and served on pita bread with traditional Greek toppings. The Philly cheesesteaks follow the Philadelphia template: thin-sliced meat on a long roll with melted cheese, sautéed onions, and peppers. Prices are modest, and portions are substantial enough that most people leave full.

Key Takeaways

• Nick's serves gyros and Philly cheesesteaks as its main offerings, with meat cooked fresh to order.
• The shop operates counter-service only, so expect to order at the register and pick up your sandwich within a few minutes.
• Toppings like tzatziki, hot peppers, and fresh vegetables come standard and can be customized to your preference.
• The location is walkable from downtown Columbia and works well for a quick weekday lunch or casual dinner.

The gyro menu and how to order

Gyros come in two main proteins: lamb-beef blend (the traditional Greek version) or chicken. Both are served on pita with tomato, onion, lettuce, and tzatziki as the base. You can add hot peppers, extra cheese, or request modifications at the counter. The lamb-beef gyro carries the strongest flavor and is closest to what you'd find in Greece or a Greek neighborhood restaurant. The chicken gyro is milder and works well if you prefer poultry or want something less rich.

Philly cheesesteaks come with your choice of steak, chicken, or Italian meats (usually a mix of salami and other cured meats). The cheese is melted over the meat, and sautéed onions and peppers are standard. You can request additional toppings or ask for modifications—no onions, extra peppers, different cheese—and the staff will adjust without fuss.

Atmosphere and seating

Nick's is a small, no-frills space with a few tables and counter seating. The décor is minimal—the focus is on the food and the speed of service, not on ambiance. It's the kind of place where you order, wait a few minutes, and either eat at one of the small tables or take your sandwich to go. The noise level is moderate during lunch and dinner rushes but manageable.

The shop is located in a strip mall or small commercial area, which means parking is usually straightforward. It's not a destination you'd plan an evening around, but it's convenient if you're in the neighborhood or looking for a quick meal downtown.

When to visit and what to expect

Lunch (11 a.m. to 2 p.m.) is the busiest time, especially on weekdays when office workers and students stop in. Dinner (5 p.m. to 8 p.m.) is steadier but less crowded. Waits are typically short—five to ten minutes even during peak hours—because the kitchen works quickly and the menu is straightforward. If you arrive during a lull, your sandwich will be ready in three to five minutes.

Nick's is open six days a week, closed on Sundays. Hours vary slightly by season, so it's worth checking ahead if you're planning a visit outside typical lunch or dinner times. The shop accepts cash and card, though it's worth confirming payment methods when you call or visit.

How Nick's fits into Columbia's Mediterranean dining scene

Nick's occupies a specific niche: affordable, quick Mediterranean sandwiches without the sit-down restaurant experience. It's less formal than a full-service Greek or Mediterranean restaurant but more authentic than a chain sandwich shop. If you're craving a gyro or Philly cheesesteak and want to eat in ten minutes, Nick's delivers. If you're looking for a leisurely meal with wine and appetizers, you'd choose a different venue.

The shop has been a consistent presence in Columbia for years, which speaks to its reliability and the loyalty of its regular customers. It's the kind of place locals know and return to, rather than a tourist destination or special-occasion spot.

Dietary considerations and customization

Vegetarian diners can request a pita with just the vegetables and tzatziki, though the menu isn't built around plant-based options. The staff will accommodate requests for no meat or extra vegetables, but the kitchen's strength is in the meat sandwiches. If you have allergies or specific dietary needs, it's best to ask the staff directly about ingredients and preparation.

Most sandwiches can be customized: extra toppings, different cheese, no onions, extra sauce. The counter staff are used to modifications and will make adjustments without hesitation. If you're unsure what to order, asking for a recommendation usually yields a straightforward answer about what's popular that day.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Nick's a good option for a quick lunch?

Yes. The counter-service model and straightforward menu mean most orders are ready in five to ten minutes, even during lunch rush. It's ideal if you have limited time and want a filling sandwich.

Can I get a vegetarian sandwich?

The menu is meat-focused, but you can order a pita with vegetables and tzatziki sauce. Ask the staff what's available—they may have fresh vegetables on hand for customization.

Do they offer delivery or takeout?

Takeout is the standard format. Delivery may be available through third-party apps, but calling ahead to order for pickup is the most reliable method.

What's the difference between the lamb and chicken gyro?

The lamb-beef gyro has a richer, more savory flavor and is the traditional Greek version. The chicken gyro is milder and lighter. Both come with the same toppings and sauce.

Are there sides or drinks included?

Sandwiches are typically served alone. Sides like fries or drinks are usually available for an additional charge. Ask what's offered when you order.