Tracey's Sweet Treats: Hand-Rolled Truffles and Seasonal Confections in Columbia

What Tracey's Sweet Treats offers and where to find it

Tracey's Sweet Treats is a small-batch confectionery in Columbia that specializes in hand-rolled truffles, fudge, and seasonal candy made fresh in-house. The shop sits on Main Street in the Five Points neighborhood, a walkable stretch of local businesses and restaurants near the University of South Carolina campus. Tracey sources ingredients locally when possible and changes the menu with the seasons—expect peppermint bark and eggnog truffles in December, strawberry and lemon flavors in spring.

The shop is open Tuesday through Saturday, with limited Sunday hours during the holiday season. You can order online for pickup or stop in to sample flavors before you buy. The space itself is small and intimate, with a display case showing the day's offerings and a few tables where you can sit with your purchase and a coffee drink.

Key Takeaways

• Tracey's hand-rolls each truffle by hand, so flavors and availability change based on what's in season and what Tracey is making that week.
• The shop is located at 2014 Main Street in Five Points, open Tuesday through Saturday from 10 a.m. to 6 p.m., with extended hours during the holiday season.
• You can order online through the website for same-day or next-day pickup, or call ahead to reserve specific flavors before they sell out.
• Prices range from individual truffles at around $2 each to gift boxes starting at $15, with custom orders available for weddings and events.
• The shop also sells fudge, brittles, and seasonal items like chocolate-covered pretzels and holiday bark that rotate monthly.

Signature flavors and what changes with the season

The core menu includes dark chocolate sea salt, milk chocolate raspberry, and white chocolate lavender—flavors Tracey keeps year-round because they sell steadily. Beyond those, the rotation depends on what's available and what Tracey feels like making. In fall, look for bourbon pecan and apple cider truffles. Winter brings peppermint bark, eggnog, and gingerbread. Spring features strawberry, lemon curd, and honey flavors. Summer leans into fruit—blueberry, peach, and passion fruit are common.

Tracey also makes sugar-free and vegan options, though availability is limited and changes week to week. If you have a flavor in mind that isn't on display, call or email ahead—Tracey often makes custom batches for regular customers or special orders. The shop's Instagram account posts new flavors as they come out, so following along is the easiest way to know what's available before you visit.

Gift boxes and custom orders for events

Tracey packages truffles in several ways depending on what you need. Single truffles are sold loose or in small paper cups for tasting. Pre-made gift boxes come in 4-piece, 9-piece, and 16-piece sizes, with your choice of flavors. The boxes are wrapped in kraft paper with a ribbon, suitable for giving as-is or taking home for yourself. Prices start around $15 for a small box and go up to $45 for the largest assortment.

For weddings, corporate events, or large parties, Tracey takes custom orders with at least two weeks' notice. You can request specific flavors, packaging colors, and quantities. She has made favors for rehearsal dinners, bridal showers, and office holiday parties. Contact the shop by phone or email to discuss your event, budget, and timeline. Custom orders typically require a deposit, with the balance due when you pick up.

How to order online and what to expect

The Tracey's Sweet Treats website has a simple ordering system where you select flavors, box size, and pickup date. Orders placed before 2 p.m. are usually ready the next day; weekend orders may take until Monday. You pay online at checkout, then pick up during regular shop hours. The website also shows which flavors are currently available, so you know before you order whether your favorite is in stock.

If you prefer to call, the shop's phone number is listed on the website and on their Five Points storefront. Tracey or a staff member can tell you what's available that day, hold flavors for you, and take your order over the phone. Payment can be made by card when you pick up or online before you arrive. During busy seasons like Valentine's Day and Christmas, online ordering fills up faster, so plan ahead if you want a specific date.

Visiting Five Points and nearby options

Tracey's sits in the heart of Five Points, a neighborhood known for independent shops, restaurants, and galleries within walking distance of each other. You can park on Main Street or in the nearby lot behind the shops. The area is pedestrian-friendly, with sidewalks connecting businesses and a few benches where you can sit outside. If you're making a day of it, nearby restaurants include Pawley's Front Porch (Southern comfort food), Lilia (Italian), and Motor Supply Co. (coffee and brunch).

The Five Points area also has a farmers market on Saturday mornings during growing season, vintage shops, and the Nickelodeon Theatre, an independent cinema. Many people combine a visit to Tracey's with lunch or coffee at another Five Points spot, or stop in after browsing nearby galleries. The neighborhood has a strong local arts and food culture, so it's worth spending an hour or two exploring if you're new to the area.

Dietary options and ingredient sourcing

Tracey works with customers who have allergies or dietary restrictions. She keeps detailed records of ingredients and can tell you which truffles contain nuts, dairy, gluten, or other common allergens. Vegan and sugar-free options are available but not always in stock, so call ahead if those are important to you. The shop is not certified nut-free, so cross-contamination is possible if that's a concern for your household.

For sourcing, Tracey prioritizes local and small-batch suppliers when the cost and quality make sense. She buys chocolate from a regional distributor, sources honey and fruit from South Carolina farms when in season, and works with local coffee roasters on flavored truffles. The ingredient list for each truffle is posted in the shop and online, so you can review what goes into your purchase before you buy.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long do truffles stay fresh?

Hand-rolled truffles are best eaten within two weeks of purchase if stored in a cool, dry place—not the refrigerator, which can cause condensation and bloom on the chocolate. Tracey includes storage instructions with every order. If you're giving them as a gift and they won't be eaten right away, ask about the best way to store them for longer shelf life.

Can I get a specific flavor if it's not on the menu?

Yes, but it depends on timing and ingredients. Call or email with your request and give Tracey at least a week's notice. She can often make custom flavors for orders of six truffles or more. Some requests may not be possible depending on ingredient availability, but she'll let you know what's feasible.

Do you ship truffles outside of Columbia?

Tracey does not currently ship, but you can place an order for pickup if you're visiting Columbia. For events or gifts that need to be mailed, ask about local shipping options or whether she can recommend a chocolatier in your area who does ship.

What's the best time to visit if I want the most flavor options?

Wednesday through Friday afternoons usually have the fullest selection, since Tracey makes fresh batches early in the week. Weekends and holidays can sell out of popular flavors by late afternoon. If you want a specific flavor, ordering online or calling ahead guarantees it will be held for you.

Are there parking and accessibility options near the shop?

Street parking is available on Main Street, and there's a small lot behind the Five Points shops. The storefront has a single step at the entrance, so wheelchair access is limited. Call ahead if you need assistance, and Tracey can help you with your order or arrange a time that works for your needs.