Cassidy's Cakes: Custom Orders and Everyday Sweets in the Midlands

What Cassidy's Cakes offers and where to find them

Cassidy's Cakes is a custom cake and dessert bakery in Columbia's Midlands area, known for made-to-order wedding cakes, birthday cakes, and specialty desserts alongside everyday pastries and sweets. The bakery works directly with customers on design, flavor, and dietary needs—whether you want a three-tier fondant creation or a simple sheet cake for a weeknight dinner. They also stock ready-made items like cupcakes, cookies, and brownies for walk-in purchases.

The bakery is located in central Columbia, making it accessible for both in-person consultations and pickup orders. Their team can discuss your vision during a tasting appointment, where you sample cake flavors and frosting options before committing to a final design.

Key Takeaways

• Cassidy's Cakes takes custom orders for weddings, birthdays, and special events, with design consultations available by appointment.
• The bakery offers flavor tastings so you can choose cake, frosting, and filling combinations before placing your order.
• Ready-made items like cupcakes and cookies are available for immediate purchase without advance notice.
• Custom cake orders require lead time—typically two to four weeks for wedding cakes and one to two weeks for smaller celebrations.
• The bakery can accommodate dietary requests including dairy-free, gluten-free, and nut-free options with advance notice.

Custom cakes for weddings and major events

Wedding cakes and large celebration cakes are Cassidy's specialty. The bakery designs tiered cakes with fondant work, fresh flowers, custom toppers, and intricate piping. You meet with a baker to review portfolio images, discuss your wedding colors and theme, and decide on structure and servings. The consultation also covers delivery and setup if your venue is within their service area.

Pricing for wedding cakes depends on size, design complexity, and flavor selections. A three-tier cake serving 75 to 100 guests costs more than a simple two-tier design, and specialty fillings or hand-painted details add to the final price. Most couples receive a quote after the tasting appointment once the design is finalized.

Lead time for wedding cakes is typically four to six weeks, though this can shift depending on the bakery's schedule during peak seasons like spring and early summer. Booking early—three to six months before your wedding—ensures your preferred date and gives the team time for detailed design work.

Birthday cakes and smaller celebrations

For birthdays, anniversaries, and smaller gatherings, Cassidy's offers custom cakes with faster turnaround. A birthday cake order usually needs one to two weeks' notice, depending on complexity. You can choose from classic designs—simple frosting with piped lettering, for example—or more elaborate themes like character cakes or geometric patterns.

The bakery also stocks sheet cakes in standard sizes for customers who want a cake ready within a few days. These come in popular flavors and can be decorated with a simple message or left plain for you to personalize at home. Cupcake orders are another option for parties, with custom flavors and toppers available.

Walk-in sweets and ready-made items

Beyond custom orders, Cassidy's sells cupcakes, cookies, brownies, and other pastries for immediate purchase. These items rotate seasonally and by availability, so what's in stock on a Monday may differ from Friday's selection. The bakery's display case typically holds several frosting flavors and decoration styles, so you can mix and match for a small gathering or grab a single treat.

Prices for walk-in items are lower than custom orders because they're made in batches. A box of six cupcakes costs less than ordering a custom-decorated half-dozen, and cookies are priced individually or by the dozen.

Flavor options and dietary accommodations

Cassidy's menu includes traditional flavors like vanilla, chocolate, and red velvet, as well as seasonal and specialty options such as lemon lavender, salted caramel, and carrot cake. Frosting choices range from American buttercream to cream cheese, Swiss meringue, and fondant. Fillings can be fruit compote, chocolate ganache, pastry cream, or custard.

The bakery works with customers who need dairy-free, gluten-free, or nut-free cakes. These orders require advance notice—usually at least two weeks—so the team can source ingredients and avoid cross-contamination in the kitchen. Vegan options are also available with prior arrangement. During your tasting appointment, let the baker know about any dietary restrictions so they can prepare samples that match your needs.

How to place an order

For custom cakes, contact Cassidy's to schedule a tasting and design consultation. You'll discuss your event date, guest count, flavor preferences, and design ideas. Bring photos or sketches of cakes you like, or describe your vision and let the baker suggest options. After the tasting, you'll receive a quote and can confirm your order with a deposit.

For walk-in purchases, simply visit during business hours and select from what's available. No advance notice is needed for ready-made items. If you want a specific flavor or decoration that isn't in stock, ask whether the bakery can prepare it for pickup the next day or later in the week.

Payment methods and cancellation policies vary, so ask about these details when you book. Most bakeries require a non-refundable deposit to hold your date, with the balance due before pickup or delivery.

Delivery and pickup options

Cassidy's offers local delivery within Columbia and the surrounding Midlands area for wedding cakes and large orders. Delivery includes setup at your venue, which is especially valuable for tiered cakes that need careful placement. Delivery fees depend on distance and complexity of setup.

For most orders, pickup at the bakery is the standard option. You'll be given a specific time window to collect your cake, usually within a few hours of your event. The bakery provides basic instructions for transporting and storing the cake so it stays fresh and intact during the drive.

Frequently Asked Questions

How far in advance do I need to order a custom cake?

Wedding cakes typically need four to six weeks' notice, though booking three to six months ahead is ideal during busy seasons. Birthday and celebration cakes usually require one to two weeks. Walk-in items need no advance notice.

Can Cassidy's make a cake for a specific dietary need?

Yes. The bakery accommodates dairy-free, gluten-free, vegan, and nut-free requests with at least two weeks' advance notice. Let them know during your tasting appointment so they can prepare samples that match your dietary needs.

What if I don't know what flavor I want?

Schedule a tasting appointment. You'll sample several cake and frosting combinations, and the baker can suggest pairings based on your preferences. This also gives you a chance to see design options and discuss your vision for the cake's appearance.

Do you deliver cakes, or is pickup only?

Cassidy's offers local delivery within Columbia and the Midlands for wedding cakes and large orders. Delivery includes setup at your venue. Pickup at the bakery is also available and is the standard option for smaller orders.

What happens if I need to cancel or change my order?

Cancellation and change policies depend on how close you are to your event date and how much work the bakery has already started. Ask about the specific policy when you place your order, as most bakeries require a non-refundable deposit to hold your date.