Broadway Bagels in Columbia: Fresh Bagels and Breakfast Sandwiches

What Broadway Bagels offers and where to find it

Broadway Bagels is a bagel shop in Columbia located on Main Street in the Five Points neighborhood. The shop makes bagels fresh daily and serves them as sandwiches, with cream cheese spreads, or plain. They also offer coffee, juice, and other breakfast items. The space is small and casual—the kind of place where regulars know the staff by name and the line moves fast during morning rush.

The shop opens early to catch the breakfast crowd and closes by early afternoon most days. Hours vary by day of the week, so calling ahead or checking their social media before your first visit saves a trip. Five Points itself is walkable, with street parking along Main Street and a few nearby lots if you need them.

Key Takeaways

• Broadway Bagels makes bagels fresh daily and serves them as sandwiches with various toppings, spreads, and proteins.
• The shop is located in Columbia's Five Points neighborhood on Main Street, a walkable area with street and lot parking nearby.
• Hours are early morning through early afternoon, with variations by day—call or check social media to confirm before visiting.
• The space is small and casual, designed for quick breakfast orders rather than lingering, though some seating is available.
• Five Points is a mixed neighborhood with other cafes, shops, and restaurants within walking distance.

Bagel varieties and sandwich options

Broadway Bagels rotates their bagel flavors, so what is available changes. Plain, everything, sesame, and poppy seed are standard offerings. Seasonal or limited-time flavors appear depending on what the bakers decide to make that week. The shop posts their daily selection on social media or you can call to ask what they have ready.

Sandwiches come built to order. You choose your bagel, then add cream cheese (plain, scallion, herb, or other spreads depending on the day), and proteins like lox, turkey, ham, or bacon. Vegetarian options include avocado, tomato, cucumber, and sprouts. Prices are moderate for a fresh bagel sandwich in a neighborhood shop—expect to spend between $6 and $12 depending on what you order.

The Five Points neighborhood and nearby spots

Five Points is one of Columbia's oldest and most walkable neighborhoods, centered around the intersection of Main, Devine, and Harden Streets. The area has a mix of independent shops, restaurants, bars, and offices, with a reputation for being quirky and community-focused. On weekends, the neighborhood draws people from across the city for brunch, shopping, and exploring.

If you are stopping by Broadway Bagels, you are already in a neighborhood worth spending time in. Other breakfast and lunch spots are within a few blocks, along with vintage shops, bookstores, and coffee roasters. The neighborhood has its own character distinct from Columbia's downtown or the shopping districts near the mall, and many people make a Five Points morning or afternoon of it rather than a single stop.

When to go and what to expect

Weekday mornings before 9 a.m. are the busiest time. The line moves quickly because the staff knows the routine and most orders are straightforward, but if you are in a hurry, arriving right when they open or after 10 a.m. means shorter waits. Weekends are busy too, but the pace is more relaxed since people are not rushing to work.

The shop itself is small—counter service only, with limited seating. Most people order and leave, though a few tables and bar seating let you eat there if you want. The bagels are best eaten fresh, so if you are taking them home, eat them within a few hours. If you are ordering for a group or event, calling ahead to let them know how many bagels you need helps them prepare.

Parking and access in Five Points

Street parking along Main Street and the surrounding blocks is free and usually available, though it fills up during peak weekend times. A few small lots are nearby if street parking is full. The neighborhood is walkable, so if you are already in Five Points for another reason, Broadway Bagels is easy to reach on foot.

The shop itself is accessible from the street with a standard entrance. If you have questions about accessibility or need specific information about parking for a particular visit, calling ahead is the best approach.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do they make bagels to order or sell what they have made?

Broadway Bagels makes bagels fresh daily and sells what they have made that morning. You cannot order a bagel flavor that is not already baked. They post their daily selection on social media or you can call to see what is available before you visit.

Can I order bagels for a party or event?

Yes, but call ahead to let them know how many bagels you need and when you want to pick them up. This gives them time to prepare and ensures they have enough of the flavors you want. They can usually accommodate orders for groups, but advance notice matters.

What are the hours?

Broadway Bagels opens early in the morning and closes by early afternoon, with hours varying by day of the week. Check their social media or call to confirm hours before you visit, especially on weekends or holidays when schedules may shift.

Is there seating inside?

Yes, there is limited seating—a few tables and bar seating. The space is small and designed mainly for counter service and quick orders, but you can eat there if you want. Most customers take their bagels to go.

Do they have vegetarian or vegan options?

Yes. You can build a vegetarian sandwich with cream cheese and toppings like avocado, tomato, cucumber, and sprouts. Ask about vegan cream cheese or spreads when you order, as availability varies by day.